Monday, February 2, 2009

The British




"The Americans are at war, the British are on operations."

http://www.economist.com/world/britain/displaystory.cfm?story_id=13022177

Most foreign militaries are fighting a war of discipline, rather than a war of survival.  The US is unique in its ability to wage such conflicts (we LOVE violence, wherever the idea came from that Americans have a weak stomach for conflict, that idea has been proven wrong over and over again.)  But there are countries for whom this IS a war of survival and whom we haven't yet tapped as a potential source of military capability.  China and Russia both need the US to do well in Iraq and Afghanistan, and to prevent the rise of a hostile Iran.  Pakistan and India have far more important contributions they can make than staring at each other across Kashmir.

In the mean time, the British military is having difficulty adapting, not as much from a lack of ingenuity as issues with institutionalism and budgeting that we have had an easier time overcoming.

Saturday, January 10, 2009

The 119th Agribusiness Development Team



The article speaks for itself:

BLOOMINGTON, Ind. (AP) - A 60-soldier Indiana National Guard unit is preparing for a mission to help farmers in Afghanistan boost production.

I hate to use the term, because its been done to death, but a big part of Stability Operations is the so-called, "Armed Social Work," that builds social, political, and economic bridges, not just among the local populace, but between the AOR and the road back home.

Meyers-Briggs is Unsubstantiated, unscientific, and statistically insignificant . . .





That being said . . . I ran the blog through this type analyzer and got this:

ISTP

The independent and problem-solving type. They are especially attuned to the demands of the moment are masters of responding to challenges that arise spontaneously. They generally prefer to think things out for themselves and often avoid inter-personal conflicts. 

The Mechanics enjoy working together with other independent and highly skilled people and often like seek fun and action both in their work and personal life. They enjoy adventure and risk such as in driving race cars or working as policemen and firefighters. 
Seems pretty accurate, but like I said over at Small Wars Journal, these things are written using terms so general, I might as well ask Miss Cleo to read my blog . . . 

Friday, January 9, 2009

Something I'm Working On.




I have been trying to figure out ways to improve the actual organization of things like the National Security Council.  This is a rough draft which incorporates the Regional Commands as implementers of Foreign Policy.  This particular chart tries to balance out regional implementation with an overarching advisory and coordination board.

Thursday, January 8, 2009

I'm on a roll tonight.



Ok kiddies, lately I have seen more and more people suggesting that the US Military is taking over foreign policy.  And frankly, this is driving me nuts.

It seems to be historical revisionism at best to suggest that the military was ever not the key foreign policy tool of the United States.
  1. Great White Fleet
  2. The Barbary Coast
  3. Gunboat Diplomacy in the Banana Republics
  4.   . . . and in China too.   The Sand Pebbles (1966) anyone?
  5. Civilize em' with a Krag
Those are just a few I could come up with off the top of my head.  But seriously, I have even heard someone who generally isn't a tinfoil-hatter suggest Gates is merely using COIN strategy to move the military into things like foreign development projects.  Gates isn't after more power, the dude has been trying to retire since the day he got the job.  He is doing his job and filling in the staggering mission gap between the State Department and Department of Defense that is right now being occupied by a ragtag group of:
  • Military COIN strategists
  • Academics in the social sciences
  • Private Contractors
  • NGOs
  • USAID FSO's
  • Some guys from Army Special Forces (the light side ones, not the dark side crowd). 
 Honestly, you probably wouldn't be able to fill a good-sized Hotel Conference Hall if you got them all together.  And yet this is the most important job in the 21st Century, these are the guys that are going to stand on the seem between war and peace and try to drag nation-states away from the brink.  So excuse the hell out of Gates for trying to make sure this job gets done.  Gates isn't talking about the militarization of foreign policy, he's talking about the diplomatization of what has historically been a military-led foreign policy.

Why isn't State doing this job?  Because State is all about working with existing Nation-states, and their institutional mindset is at the embassy in Paris, not Baghdad. I like this quote by Nagl and Fick over at ForeignPolicy.com: 
This imperative to get out among the people extends to U.S. civilians as well. U.S. Embassy staff are almost completely forbidden from moving around Kabul on their own. Diplomacy is, of course, about relationships, and rules that discourage relationships fundamentally limit the ability of American diplomats to do their jobs. The mission in Afghanistan is to stabilize the country, not to secure the embassy.
 The part that I made bold should be tattooed on some peoples foreheads.  And honestly, I like the idea of a separate organization for each part of the Defense, Development, and Diplomacy blend.  The so-called, "3D" Approach.  Department of Defense gets shrunk, State Department stays the same minus USAID, and a new Department of International Development built on the guys I listed above gets a hefty chunk of change.  Use the existing Unified Command regions, each Command has a Presidentially appointed Director, and a Deputy Director from DoD, DoS, and DID.  Good luck prying anything away from Secretary of State Clinton.
Oh well, a kid can dream can't he?

Join the Mobile Infantry!

Why no National Call to Service?  Why not empower the youth of this nation and motivate them to be part of something larger than themselves?  The President has not once, not ever, asked for people to join Americorps, Peace Corps, or the US Military, despite informing us rather consistently that we are indeed at war.  This has always bugged me, why not ask for volunteers?  Instead, the only thing he has ever asked of the American public is to shop.  Had the president asked for people to join the military when he addressed the nation that evening on September 11th, 2001, the recruiting offices would have been overwhelmed.  Instead we simply overwhelmed our creditors, and shopped away.

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

AFRICOM starts sneaking into Darfur . . .



http://www.stripes.com/article.asp?section=104&article=59831

The term, "quiet escalation" isnt generally applied to peacekeeping, but that seems to be what is happening here.  Its difficult for other countries to support the US in this endeavor because of national sovereignty issues that apply to so many of our partners and even allies.  But gradual escalation of peacekeeping, especially if we remain primarily a logistical partner, might be more palatable to the global community, which does want to see something positive happen, it just doesn't know what.  It is truly time for the US to return to the leadership role in these sorts of affairs.